Under age magic - just wondering?

wildirishrose01us wildirishrose at fiber.net
Mon Nov 2 04:43:13 UTC 2009


No: HPFGUIDX 188327



Carol:
I happen to agree with you though not necessarily with regard to this example. Even in SS/PS, we have the Charlie Weasley problem and the Missing Twenty-four hours, which I suppose the copyeditor either didn't notice or thought was beyond the scope of his or her job (there was no consistency editor at that point since it was the first book). The project editor may or may not have noticed those problems but probably thought they weren't worth worrying about in a first novel/children's book that might not even sell.

Marianne:

Again. ???  The missing 24 hours???  Charlie Weasley problem????

Sorry I came on this list halfway through DH so I missed a lot of the discussions.





More information about the HPforGrownups archive