Under age magic - just wondering?
Geoff
gbannister10 at tiscali.co.uk
Mon Nov 2 20:03:52 UTC 2009
No: HPFGUIDX 188334
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "bboyminn" <bboyminn at ...> wrote:
bboyminn:
> There is a missing 24 hours between when Harry's parents are
> killed and when Harry was dropped off at the Dursley on Privet
> Drive. Where was Harry during that time? Who was taking care
> of him?
> Why did they fly in from Bristol in the west, and not
> from the north in the direction of Hogwarts and Scotland?
> I suggest, to the last item, that they (Hagrid and Harry)
> may have flow straight south over the Iris Sea, the near
> Bristol, turned East and flew into Surrey. Seem like a good
> idea until someone pointed out that the Irish Sea is a
> training ground for the Royal Air Force, and is likely a
> 'no fly' zone for any one other than scheduled commercial
> airlines. Not really a safe place to be flying around on a
> flying motorcycle.
>
> The implication is that Hagrid flew in from near Bristol,
> further implying that Harry was stashed near Bristol during
> that missing 24 hour period. But, it has never been explained.
Geoff:
Because, Steve, you're barking up the wrong tree. They didn't fly
from the north.
Just in passing, although the Irish Sea is used as a training area
by the RAF, there is still a lot of non-military and non-scheduled
air traffic around. Where I live on Exmoor (on the south side of the
Bristol Channel), there are a lot of military movements. I frequently
curse RAF Tornados going over me at about 500-1000 feet when
I'm trying to have a quiet stroll with the dog and we also get Hercules
practising their low flying techniques as well as a lot of light
aircraft, business helicopters and the Air Ambulance going overhead
all the time plus commercial flights out of Cardiff Rhoose, fifteen
miles away across the Channel. Military activities rarely close areas
completely. We're too small a country for that.
But to get back on topic. Harry's parents James and Lily were killed at
Godric's Hollow. There was a lot of discussion on this topic a few years
back in which it was suggested that the village was in South Wales
which would tie in with Hagrid's flight path.
However, since then, other information has surfaced, to wit:
'"The villages of Tinworth in Cornwall, Upper Flagley in Yorkshire and
Ottery St. Catchpole on the south coast of England were notable
homes to knots of wizarding families who lived alongside tolerant and
sometimes Confunded Muggles. Most celebrated of these half-magical
dwelling places is, perhaps, Godric's Hollow, the West Country village
where the great wizard Godric Gryffindor was born and where Bowman
Wright, wizarding smith, forged the first Golden Snitch."'
(DH "Godric's Hollow" p.261 UK edition)
Now, there has been a body of opinion which holds that Ottery St.
Catchpoleis near Ottery St. Mary, a town in South Devon, just east of
Exeter which is also well into the West Country. However, if Godric's
Hollow had been in that area, Hagrid's flight to Little Whinging would
have taken him well to the south of Bristol, his destination, which I believe
from canon evidence, lies to the west of London not far from Heathrow
Airport.
However, if Godric's Hollow lay in the northern area of the West Country
- North Cornwall, North Devon or even my own West Somerset, a flight
line could be nearer to Bristol. I think it would be more likeyl to be the
first two counties I have named because a direct flight line towards
London would take Hagrid and baby Harry along the Bristol Channel
making landfall at Weston-super-Mare and then travelling over Bath.
However, it is feasible that Hagrid may have steered sufficiently far north,
five or six miles or so, to be skirting the southern suburbs of Bristol.
Bristol is an extensive city. By coincidence, I had occasion two days ago
to go to Reading for a conference and my train headed well up towards
Bristol before heading more due east.
As regards Harry possibly being kept overnight - and where - remains
a source of speculation.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive