Wizarding Top Ten

[happyjoeysmiley]

No: HPFGUIDX 188015

> > Joey's take:
> > 1. Hermione [For the intense concern she has for her loved ones / oppressed which she shows in the form of solid action; her conscience]
> 
> Kemper now:
> Hermione took her parents basic rights away.  It was disgusting.  She cared only for her conscience and imposed it willynilly.  

Joey:

Hmm. Interesting perspective. :-) 

Um, but does canon say anything about Hermione discussing (or not discussing) her plans with her parents before she modified their memories? I somehow feel that she would have (tearfully and apologetically) explained to them why she was going to do what she did just before she modified their memories (and probably, they consented).

In this case, I also think that she cared for her parents' safety and welfare. I too would rather that my parents are safe in Australia knowing nothing about their true identities than being Crucio-ed / killed by a set of nutters calling themselves Death Eaters.

Let me know what you think. :-)

Cheers,
~Joey :-)