[HPforGrownups] Re: Wizarding Top Ten

[Meliss9900 at aol.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 188023

In a message dated 10/14/2009 9:13:40 A.M. Central Daylight Time,  
iam.kemper at gmail.com writes:

Kemper  now:
If I were Mr or Mrs Granger, I would ask Hermione if Ron's parents  would 
be consenting to a modified memory. Of course, they would not. But,  then, 
Hermione might lie as she has no problem with deceiving others if she  
believes its for the best (see confundus charm on McLaggen.)
That's comparing apples and oranges.  Mr & Mrs Weasley are adult  wizards 
and  capable of defending themselves and their family from a  magical attack. 
The Grangers aren't.  I suppose that they could have tried  the Fidelius 
(sp) charm but seeing how well it worked for Harry's parents,  Hermione might 
not have enough faith to trust her parents to it.
 
Kemper:

I  believe you are right, in that they would trust her to go with Harry but 
that  they would be understandably fearful for their daughter's life. But 
that's  part of the consequence of Hermione's (or any other  
fighter/warrior/I  believe you are right, in that they would trust her to go with Harry but 
that  they would be understandably fearful for their daughter's life. But 
that's  part of the consequence of Hermione's (or any other  
fighter/warrior/<WBR>soldier's)


True but that doesn't settle the matter of whether or not they could  have 
discussed the option or it they agreed. We just don't have the canon  (or 
interview material) to support either claim.
 
Melissa
 
 
 


Kemper






[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]