Hermione and her parents redux WAS: Re: Wizarding Top Ten

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 188073



> Pippin:
> True. A memory charm won't protect the Grangers from an interrogation by LV, and if they should stumble into his clutches the way poor Bertha did, Hermione's plan would fail. But she knows that. The memory charm protects the Grangers, and therefore Hermione herself, by keeping   the DE's from using any information about the Grangers which they already have to locate them or lure them out of hiding.


Alla:

I really think that it depends, I really think that memory charm could increase their chances to stand interrogation as well if done by lesser wizard than Voldemort.

But what do you mean by memory charm placed on Grangers would stop DE from finding information about them?

Do you think that DE, if they try cannot go and find Grangers by their pictures for example? I mean many DE seem quite stupid to me, but say they were good detectives, I just do not get if you are saying that memory charm will work like something that would not let police dogs smell, or are you saying something else?

Thanks,

Alla