What could happen in the books WAS :Re: Were the Weasleys (particularly Molly) i

[goldenscarabofegypt]

No: HPFGUIDX 188172

Alla:

> But if writer did not say it did it happen?
> 
> My answer is of course it did not happen, otherwise how we are supposed to discuss the story if your story is different from what author wanted to tell us?
> 
> I did and probably will disagree with the interpetations of what actually can be considered a hint based on which our imaginations run wild, but if there is no sign of something in the book whatsoever, not even a hint to based it on, yes, I would say that it did not happen.
> 
> I want to say that Harry apparated on Mars for the fun of it. Are you really saying that it could have happened?


Scarabsi:
Forgive me, but I wish to point out quickly that this person's suspicions about the Weasley's history with the OoP are risen from the strange behavior of the Order members, which is what caused them to have this theory in the first place (and I cannot say that the theory doesn't sound plausible, either).

On the other hand, there is nothing in any of the books that would even remotely suggest that Harry had ever been to Mars, and in fact the very build of his character makes it even less likely - Antisocial introvert Harry Potter, who shies away from his own somewhat-earned fame, do such a flashy and pointless action as Apparating into space, when he doesn't even like Apparating in the first place? This is without even going into whether Harry would know how to survive in space without a spacesuit and other details like that which are just taking the silly-bait.

I find that the comparison does not adequately explain why you would dismiss the mentioned possibility with the reason that you gave. Oh, I can likely guess what you meant, and it is a fair and sensible argument in itself. . . just not when it involves out-of-context intergalactic travels to Pigfarts.

Scarabsi, who had meant to make a short, quick post, honest.