[HPforGrownups] Re: Lily being spared

[lui]

No: HPFGUIDX 189842

<snip>

June: 
> I am aware of all those things, I have read the books several 
times but in my opinion those things only led up to what happened 
and it was totally Lily's love that cast the spell. That is the 
way I understood it and I thought this group was all about 
discussing the book and voicing out opinions. You seem to think 
it is all about everyone has no right to an opinion and yours is 
the only one that's right. <

luirhys:
Sorry if I'm coming across that way, I did not mean to demean 
your opinion. I just wanted to clear the fact that if it had 
been Neville's mother, or any other mother- even though 
undoubtedly, they would shield and sacrifice themselves for 
their child- it would not have the same effect. We not have 
another boy/girl who lived. 

Which makes me think, would the series have worked if it was a "Harrieta"?