The Prophecy (was Re: Lily being spared)

[June Ewing]

No: HPFGUIDX 189865

Potioncat:
> So we agree? DD says there are 2 boys who could fit the prophecy,
the prophecy doesn't say there are 2 candidates.

I take this to mean that DD feels LV had to choose between 2 boys
that it could have been, and LV chose Harry. I still maintain that
if LV had chosen Neville first, he could still have attacked Harry
and marked Harry as his equal. <


June:
I never said it was the prophecy that said it was two boys (and
stop making me type that work because I know I am spelling it
wrong lol). Dumbledore said there were two boys it fit but you
have a point. If he had gone after Neville and killed Neville he
probably would have the same affect on Harry if he had gone after
him too, however if he had gone after Neville first and killed
him don`t you think it would have been likely that he would have
just considered it job done and not gone after Harry at all? But
then again Voldemort being Voldemort maybe just to be save would
have gone after Harry anyway. Here's a thought, do you think
there was a third boy killed before Harry that Dumbledore didn't
mention? LOL










[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]