Snape and Harry

James Lyon jnoyl at aim.com
Mon Feb 15 17:57:13 UTC 2010


No: HPFGUIDX 188921

First, was the memory true and did Harry know what all led to the  
scene? Does he know the context of Snape's tormenting?
Then, there is the actual canon!Snape (not the movie!Snape, but the  
canon!Snape) who abuses children and mind rapes them? Who doesn't  
teach but punishes after the children blow up their potions? The  
Snape who believes that love means it is OK to kill a woman's husband  
and baby to get her as a pet or sex slave?
Did Snape apologize for getting Harry's parents killed? Did any of  
the adults ever act like adults?
Besides, an apology from any one other than the one who committed the  
"outrage" is meaningless and insipid.
JL




More information about the HPforGrownups archive