Chapter Discussion Chamber of Secrets Ch. 7 Mudbloods and Murmurs

[potioncat]

No: HPFGUIDX 188944


> 
> Geoff:
> Speaking from my experience as a teacher, some of which time involved 
> me with games, it didn't have to happen.
> 
> There should have been time available for Slytherin to have their own 
> practice slot. I wonder whether Marcus Flint had approached Snape and 
> asked for the time without going further or whether Snape was just being
> Snapeish.

Potioncat:
I was thinking the same thing--actually a random teacher shouldn't be able to take someone's field time; the only person wtih authority over the field should be Madam Hooch. But what 6th year would argue with Snape? We never find out how the issue is resolved, because we follow the Trio to Hagrid's.

Geoff:
> 
> I can remember getting quite cross with a colleague many years ago under 
> similar circumstances. 
snip
 There was a lively 
> exchange of views - but fortunately no slugs.
> :-)

Potioncat:
Too bad you didn't know the spell back then. ;-)
>