Harry, Snape and Dementors WAS: Re: CHAPTER Chamber of Secrets Chapter 18:

[nikkalmati]

No: HPFGUIDX 189337


Alla said
>To me Harry disagreeing with Snape be it in written OR oral form pretty much
equals Harry challenging Snape. We KNOW that Patronus method is effective in
fighting Dementors, we saw it, in fact we know that Patronus can fight a whole
lot of Dementors. I think that grade that Harry deserved is Outstanding. Oh
wait, I see. Are you saying that since we never know what grade Harry actually
got it is not a given that Snape gave him a low grade? If that's what you are
arguing then I disagree, but could you please clarify if you are arguing
>something different?

Nikkalmati

Maybe his grade was unremarkable. Just what Harry expected - neither low nor high.

Nikkalmati