Harry, Snape and Dementors WAS: Re: CHAPTER Chamber of Secrets Chapter 18:

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 189358



Potioncat:
<SNIP>
We don't know if Snape himself compared the two methods or simply taught one. 

Alla:

I disgree. To me disagreeing with Snape's method is a clear indication that he only taught one. He does not say he disagreed with method that Snape preferred. IMO.

Potioncat:
We
don't know what mark Harry was given, or if Snape commented in any way on the
paper. At worst Harry must have gotten the score he expected--we don't read
later that Snape gave him an Outstanding nor do we learn that he made an
especially nasty remark or took any other notable action. We don't know if
Harry's essay answered the question, or went off on a tangent. All we know is
that Harry used the assignment to voice his opinion about the Patronum Charm. <SNIP>

Alla:

Sure, we do not know what mark Harry was given at the end, I however explained upthread why I believe that he got a low mark, I think otherwise he would most definitely commented on it. Unless you go with Pippin's reasoning that Harry would not have care to comment (as if it is so normal for Harry to get a good grade from Snape lol) on it. I do not buy it. IMO of course.

Pippin, you just commented in the post that I responded to that Harry wrote the essay on such important topic for him  that saved his life and life his loved one with the only purpose in mind to annoy Severus Snape, but Harry would not have commented if he got a good grade on it. Really?