Chapdisc Cos 12

kemper iam.kemper at gmail.com
Wed Mar 31 04:25:46 UTC 2010


No: HPFGUIDX 189091

   
> Bart:
> ... I think that one of the themes of the books which, unfortunately, was not as well resolved as the others, was the way that the House system could do more harm than good, and the need for more cooperation between the Houses. 
> Yes, Sevvy made his choice, but a whole slew of friends telling him how great he was trumped one girlfriend who was almost ashamed to publicly admit that she was his friend (note that Hermoine and Ginny had no problem being friends with Luna).

Kemper:
I think you got that last part a bit backwards. It's Luna who has no problem being friends with Hermione.

I agree about the reader's (or at least this reader's)anticipation of  Houses unification being a big dud.

Kemper





More information about the HPforGrownups archive