HP7 - SPOILER

[AmanitaMuscaria]

No: HPFGUIDX 189769



--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "catmcnulty" <CatMcNulty at ...> wrote:
>
> I have been reading everyone's comments about parts they liked and disliked ... I am not going to repeat what has already been discussed (I hope). There is a moment that just haunts me, and I wonder why they left Mad-Eye's eye in Umbrage's door? I liked the book's solution and the honor with which Harry treated the moment. It was like what he did with Dobby.
> 
> Also,what was with Runcorn's funny little walk? Yes, he was supposed to be Harry but he looked like he was trying to do a Monty Python skit ... Remember the bureau of "Funny Walks"? Very odd.
> 
> Cat >^-.-^<
>

AmanitaMuscaria now - Agreed - I'm not sure wwhy they didn't follow the book there; I thought the scene in the book very much pointed up Harry's character, that he could distance himself from the idea of False!Moody, who, of course, he had much more time with, and offer respect to True!Moody. It wouldn't have taken more than a quick flashback to Moody herding them all indoors, then him taking the eye.
But then, the film had Harry leaving the Snitch several times, and the thing acted like a homing pigeon. In the book, he valued Dumbledore's legacy much more.
It wasn't just Runcorn's walk; it looked to me like he was robot-dancing some of the time.