[HPforGrownups] CHAPTER DISCUSSION: Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban Chapter 11: The Fir

[June Ewing]

No: HPFGUIDX 189776

When Harry imagined Black with Voldemort, did you think it was just Harry's imagination?

June
Yes it was Harry's imagination because it had been put into his head that Sirius had worked with Voldemort.


What did you think when the Sneakoscope went off?

June
The Sneakoscope went off every time Scabbers was around because Scabbers was not what he pretended to be. He was Peter Petigrew and if you look back to the times the Sneakoscope went off Scabbers was always there.


Did you think Trelawney's 'when thirteen dine together, the first to rise will be the first to die' saying was real? What did you think of the other teachers' reactions to Trelawney?
 
June
I do not think it is real. Just silly superstition. I am with Hermione and Professor McGonagal in thinking that Devination is a dodgy subject.


Did you think the Firebolt could have been sent by Sirius Black? Why did the fact it was anonymous disturb everyone so much?
 
June
The Firebolt was sent by Sirius Black. I suspected that in the first place and it turned out to be true. The reason everyone was concerned about the anonymous gift was because they (thought) Sirius was out to get Harry and the broom could be a way of getting to him. They thought (as Hermione stated) that it could be jinxed.