CHAPTER DISCUSSION: Prisoner of Azkaban Chapter 7: The Boggart in the Wardrobe

[Joey Smiley]

No: HPFGUIDX 189555

Megan wrote:
> Questions:
 
> 1. What does Hermione's punishment for helping Neville say about Snape?

Joey:

Before reading DH, I thought he was just being nasty to a Gryffindor. Now, I think maybe, just maybe, he was trying to make Neville independent (in his own horrible way :-)).
 
> 2. What did you think Lupin's boggart was the first time you read the chapter?

Joey:

I was imagining something like the dome of a bed lamp, in silver colour.
 
> 3. What did you think Malfoy meant by his comment about how Harry should want revenge on Sirius Black the first time you read the chapter?

Joey:

I wondered why he said "revenge" and then thought he was probably only just saying that Harry should get back at Sirius for having supported the "Dark Lord" and for having trying to get Harry.
 
> 4. What did you think Hermione's boggart would have been?

Joey:

I had never considered Hermione as a person who had significant fears in her heart. Only when I saw the way she reacted to her exam results in HBP, I agreed with Ron's guess about her boggart.
 
> 5. Did you think that boggarts would play a significant role in the rest of the story?

Joey:

I thought so, for they had been given such a significant introduction.

Thanks for the summary and questions! :-)