MOVIE: Sorry for the Rant - PU to DH2

kamion53 kersberg at chello.nl
Wed Aug 31 15:23:53 UTC 2011


No: HPFGUIDX 191325


> 
> Steve:
> - I saw Goblet of Fire last week, and in the scene where Harry and Cedric return to the Maze from the graveyard, and Cedric's father rushes down to see his son's body, the actor playing Amos Diggory is acting his brains out, but the scene is unnatural because anyone with that much anguish over the death of their son would have embraced the body. He would have held Cedric in his arms, refusing to let him go. That happens in real life. But in the movie, it seems to be all about the right camera angle, because Amos never touches the body. And I mean NEVER touches the body. ===> 
> Steve/bboyminn
>

strange, but I remember that scene as Amos intensely hugging his sons body.... wether it happened or not.
even used it as inspiration for a fanfic picture with Lucius and Draco in place. 
I sort of imagined that Lucius would willenly backstap his master when Voldemort killed his son for his eyes. Kind of avoided the problem of killing Voldy without Harry's soul damaged.
well JKR had a better solution, although I missed the rebounched AK in the movie too.
my friend, who don't read the books, did not miss it at all, so I think it is more an educated fan problem, then a cinematic problem.





More information about the HPforGrownups archive