[HPforGrownups] New member

[dorothy dankanyin]

No: HPFGUIDX 191465

Hi Otto,
  Since you've only watched two of the films, in my opinion they're the only 
two that are close to the books.  I've seen the other films, and all I can 
do is find stuff that doesn't agree with the books.
  I hope and know you'll have fun here learning about all the other members 
who all have differing, but interesting opinions.
  Dorothy

From: <sigurd at eclipse.net>
Sent: Monday, December 12, 2011 2:47 PM


> Dear List
>
> Just joined, read all the books, saw only 1 and 2 of the movies. Liked the 
> books better. I read the books at the behest of my "ersatz Grandchildren" 
> and now am re-reading applying a bit of lit-crit and analysis to them.
>
> Look forward to interesting discussions.
>
> What I am finding intersting is tracing the themes, tropes and 
> similarities in characters, thoughts, and concepts with other fantasy and 
> sci-fi fiction writers.
>
> Otto