Slytherin house

[willsonteam]

No: HPFGUIDX 191627


> Nikkalmati
> 
> JKR is leading us astray again. You really can't take at face value what any one says in her books, but "by their fruit you shall know them" is the way to analyze the works.  Then you see she puts good characters in all the Houses and bad ones too.  


Potioncat:
What if, instead of naming all the bad guys from Slytherin, we named the good guys from each house? I was thinking that I can name several Slytherins, but I'm not sure how many Hufflepuffs or Ravenclaws I can name. I'm not sure how this will play out, but here goes.

Of course, in some cases we may debate whether the person was a good guy or not--and some good guys or bad guys had no real role in the final battle. So, for right now, I'm naming Slytherins who opposed LV in some way.

Regulus Black
Severus Snape
Horace Slughorn
Andromeda Black Tonks (Unless it isn't canon she was Slytherin)

Narcissa Malfoy undermined or sabotaged LV twice I can think of.
Draco Malfoy attempted to resist several times and undermined a couple of times.
Portrait Phineas Nigellus Black 

Someone I think was Slytherin but don't think it's canon--the senior Crouch.

Anyone up for one of the other Houses?

Potioncat