Slytherin house

kamion53 kersberg at chello.nl
Sat Dec 31 18:32:56 UTC 2011


No: HPFGUIDX 191640



--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, Eric Oppen <technomad at ...> wrote:
>(**)
 What??? You left Dolores Umbridge out of the competition?  How could  
> you?  Or the Carrows, or Quirrel...frankly, the quality of the faculty  
> at that school does not impress me in general.
> 
(**) in his class...this is a recipe for disaster; Malfoy would probably  
> have found a way to injure himself with flobberworms if he could blame  
> it on Hagrid.

I left Umbridge and the Carrows out, because those were forched on Hogwarts, they also deliberately undermined the teaching.
Quirrel is a grey area, there is no indication he teached in a bad way, Umbridge and the Carrows were no choice of Dumbledore ( or Snape I think)
one could on the other hand include Snape himself, who although rather brilliant himself has no skills to handle lesser gifted pupils.

on the whole teaching at Hogwarts during the Potter years is substandard, Dumbledore is far more concerned battling Voldemort then keeping up high standards and willing so sacrifice anything for it.





More information about the HPforGrownups archive