Dumbledore and Snape and bigotry WAS:Re: Chapter Discussion: Prisoner of Azkaban

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 190734





> > Librasmile:
> > I certainly don't expect cheerleaders for Snape but I do expect to see some acknowledgement that there equally valid counter arguments against seeing Snape as purely evil. However, that's not what I see. I simply see the equivalent of partisan radio or talk shows.
> > 
> >
> Nikkalmati
> 
> Actually Alla has softened up quite a bit on Snape since DH!:>)


Alla:

My goodness, do you remember post HBP debates Nikkalmati? Did he do it? Did he not? Did he do it? Did he? And if he did it, why? So much passion and fun. Yeah, good old times :)

> > Alla:
> > 
> > Absolutely agreed, but what does this have to do with Snape's ideas? Sorry I am just confused.
> 
> Nikkalmati
> 
> The ideas Snape embraces on the superiority of wizards over Muggles, which are promoted by LV, came from DD and Grindenwald.  DD is atleast partly responsible for LV and his Death Eaters and he probably knows it.

Alla:

Oh my god. Talk about getting new insights and enlightment lol. I mean, of course I did not forget that Dumbledore shared those ideas with Grindelwald and wanted to see it in life, the wizards superiority and muggles. Its just believe it or not, I do not think I ever made a direct link of responsibility that Dumbledore must have for Voldemort and death eaters. But wait, are we sure that Dumbledore and Gridenwald were the first ones to bring these ideas in wizard society or it was already spread and they just picked upon it and run with it?I wonder if Voldemort studied Dumbledore's and Grindelwald's works and decided to adopt them heh.

 Well, regardless I think now I just got a legit reason to hate Dumbledore even more than I do :). Thanks Nikkalmati