Harry's alleged debt to Dumbledore and Snape WAS: Re: Chapter Discussion

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 190859


> Bart:
>      I am referring to AK before King's Cross. Yes, it was confusing, 
> but to a number of us here, it is absolutely key to the color of 
> Dumbledore's actions.

Alla:

Actually this one I find the least confusing. I went to reread Kings cross and yeah the part I always found confusing is still confusing, but not this one. Or maybe this one is my simplistic understanding and this is not what JKR intended either. So, in my opinion when he half died and his soul went for a walk to this place where he met with Dumbledore the horcrux part of it died and the rest of him survived and now their souls are not connected. The only connection are their wands.

What I always found confusing is what taking Harry's blood in did to Voldemort. Dumbledore gives the shpill about Voldemort's body keeping her sacrifice alive and I always found it wierd, wasn't the whole point of her blood allegedly protecting Harry at Dursleys is that it is alive where her blood dwells?.

So we can go forward now? :)