varying views of characters

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 191095

> Alla:
> > Personally I think that no one was the source of Dumbledore's evidence. This is of course just speculation, but to me perfectly in line with how I see Dumbledore's character. I think he just made one of his famous guesses, only this time it was totally wrong, and he was under delussion that it was correct as usual.
> >
> 
> Bart:
>      Now that make sense. Especially considering that the entire WW Came 
> to the same conclusion, including, based on what we saw with Snape, many 
> if not most of the Death Eaters.


Alla:

Why exactly is this strange? I mean it is not like what happened to Potters and subsequent indictment of Sirius by public opinion and ministry and Dumbledore was a secret affair. Yes of course the whole WW came to that conclusion after the fact. I thought we were discussing who knew before the fact and the only people who really KNEW were Potters, Sirius and Peter. Of course we also have members of the OOP (also not that many people really) who thought they knew.

JMO,

Alla, who is so happy that power is back in her appartment.