Chapter Discussion: Prisoner of Azkaban Ch 18: Moony, Wormtail, Padfoot and Pron

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 190509

Eh sorry for doing multiple posting guys, I will be good tomorrow I promise, but may I just say how very amusing I find the real world legal comparisons with what punishment Sirius would have received? Would he been charged with attempted murder or complicity to commit murder? I would have said it is pretty much a given, the charge that is.

Now, conviction? You want to bet that good attorney would have at least been able to mitigate the charges? And before you ask me, yes I do know , not just saying it because I watch "Law and order".

Having said it, it is completely irrelevant to the point I am making. Yes, Snape could have been killed, as I said several times and never disputed that. All I am disputing is taking away Snape's choice in what have happened. Had he never went there, nothing would have happened.

Sirius made the task easier for him, which he had no business to do, but thats all he did, and again his mindset is also irrelevant for what I am saying. He could have just beeing a teenager idiot, he could have wanted to kill Snape, makes no difference in my opinion.

He still did not *make* Snape to go there.

JMO,

Alla