[HPforGrownups] harry potter in general

[Bart Lidofsky]

No: HPFGUIDX 190567

nerona wrote:
> Snape had an agreement moment, you know what I mean?? A moment of understanding although there is nothing they would agree on.

Bart:
     I've mentioned that one thing I wish JKR had done was to put at 
least one Slytherin student who proved to be one of the good guys. Even 
having one in the DA; with the attitude, "That's just school games, this 
is for REAL!"
> I know for sure that every character was perfectly formed to fit the story line, but for me I can't understand why JK Rowling killed almost everyone Harry cares or would have cared about, like his parents for a start, then Sirius, then Dumbledore, even his Owl, so I know that at some point she had to kill 1 of these characters but why all of them???
Bart:
     Most of the Weasley's survive (and face it, the way it was written, 
Fred & George were a single entity with two bodies anyway). Minnie the 
Cat and Hagrid survive. Hermione survives. Actually, the whole group of 
friends who went to the Battle of the Ministry survive. Just to name a few.

     Bart