Harry Potter in general - Above and Below
nerona
nerona12 at yahoo.com
Sun Jun 19 14:17:59 UTC 2011
No: HPFGUIDX 190582
> Steve:
> Notice one thing about all the people who died, they all stood
above Harry. They were all people Harry looked up to. The people
who remained are all people who looked up to Harry. They stood as
his equals or, from a certain perspective, his subordinates.
>
> When the final battle came, JKR wanted Harry isolated, she wanted
this to be a battle between Harry and Voldemort with no hero of
Harry's able to step in and save the day.
>
> The weight had to fall on Harry's shoulders and his alone. And
that meant that everyone who stood above Harry, figuratively
> speaking, had to be gone.
Nerona:
That's a good point, now I can see it more clearly, but hasn't she
put at least 1 scene of understanding between Harry and Snape, it
illogic for Harry to hate Snape all these years, and Snape hating
him back and then because of a memory Harry names his own son after
him.
Now for me since book 5 I started suspecting that Snape is doing
something good although it wasn't revealed until book 7 (at the
end) but why not have 1 single scene that contains an agreement or
understanding, you know what I mean? I wish I read 1 scene with
Harry and Snape doing something together.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive