Cedric, Snape and carma was re: Chapter Discussion: Prisoner of Azkaban

[jacob brandt]

No: HPFGUIDX 190609

> Librasmile:
> <snip> I'm a complete absolute Snape fan. I don't see him as 
flawless. But it still puzzles me that people can see him being 
harassed for years and then NOT see that incident in the Shack 
as an attempt to kill him. <snip> As far as I'm concerned Sirius 
intended to kill, didn't give a rat's ass what would have happened 
to Lupin ( until after the fact when he realized that LUPIN could 
have been killed ), and James was only saving the Marauders' a**'s 
> when he saved Snape. <snip>


Jacob:
When Dumblebore dueled Grindelwald and beat him to obtain the 
deathstick do you believe Grindelwald was dueling to kill?