Cedric, Snape and carma was re: Chapter Discussion: Prisoner of Azkaban

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 190625



.> > 
> Nikkalmati:
> 
> Ok lets speculate.  If Snape was killed in the Shack, was James killed also?  That's one possibility.  If just Snape was killed, I presume Lupin would have been exposed and possibly killed also, but this time by the Wizarding judicial system.  Would DD have remained at Hogwarts?  Would there have been a Prophecy?  It looks like DD would have been humiliated at the least.  There would have been no Order of the Phoenix and no stopping Voldemort. I doubt anyone would have lived a longer or a happier life. IMHO


Alla:

Agreed of course. Nobody can predict how one event would have changed the lifes of others. I am just saying that what would have made me happy if I see characters as *real people* is Snape's death with no consequences to Lupin and Black, again because of what he does in the future to Harry and his family. Now of course no consequences is not possible, thus no matter how much I wanted bastard dead and not able to torment Harry for years and contribute to depriving him of his family, sure I do not want Sirius and Lupin to have murder on their hands and be imprisoned or probably dead, you know?

Now if tiny little Nagini was playing around the Shrieking Shack and one day decided to eat little Snape when he was spying on Marauders, oh yeah that would have been a scenario that I would have liked.

Again let me stress, am happy with the story, just describing my fantasy scenario.