Chapter Discussion: Prisoner of Azkaban Ch 16: Professor Trelawney's prediction

June Ewing doctorwhofan02 at yahoo.ca
Wed May 4 18:52:51 UTC 2011


No: HPFGUIDX 190373

> Taya:
> I have just had a thought. Dumbledore always seems to know what
is going on at Hogwarts, could he therefore know (or have seen)
Harry and Hermione in 2 separate locations at the same time? Then
he must surely know they had gone back in time, and this would
probably lead him to thinking it was he who sent them back, owing
> to how seriously Hermione took not breaking rules.

> I will also mention (carefully, as it's not mentioned in the
books but we can speculate!) that it may be possible that some of
the gadgets in Dumbledore's office, keep track of all things at
Hogwarts, students included, or indeed that he may have a Marauder's
> Map himself.


June:
Good thought Taya, it makes so much sense and I bet you are correct.
Dumbledore too being Dumbledore would have caught on right away too
when he saw two Harrys and Hermiones and not been the least bit
surprised lol.











More information about the HPforGrownups archive