[HPforGrownups] Re: Time travel/ was:Chapter Discussion: Prisoner of Azkaban Ch 16

[Shelley Gardner]

No: HPFGUIDX 190380


> June:
> I agree with Shelley. It is logical that with Buckbeak set for
> execution, Dumbledore did know at the time what he was going to do
> in the future and kept them from looking out the window. What
> confuses me though is was the American version so different that
> all three of them went back in time? In the version I have Ron is
> in the hospital wing, but this is the second time someone has said
> all three of them went back in time. I think we should all trade
> books, it will be like reading new books for all of then lol.

Shelley:
My mistake was pointed out and corrected in another post. Quoting it 
now, in case you missed it:


>> --- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, Shelley Gardner<k12listmomma at ...>   wrote:
>>
>> Shelley:
>>> I find it hard to believe, as you suggest, that Dumbledore guesses that
>>> he will have, in a future time, allowed Hermione the use of the
>>> Time-Turner, and thus he alone knew, as it was happening, that there
>>> were two Grangers, two Potters and two Weasleys present that he needed
>>> to stall for with a cup of tea at Hagrids.
>> Geoff:
>> I hope you will forgive my being pedantic - and a pain in the backside for
>> being so - but the Dramatis Personae for this scene were two Grangers,
>> two Potters and ONE Weasley.
> Oh sorry, you are totally right! Ron was back at the hospital wing.....
>
> Shelley