Filling in the blanks: Snape, DD and Snuffles

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 190422



> Julie:
> Well, one of the first things Sirius did when he and Snape
> met up again was to bang Snape's head into the ceiling,
> deliberately and repeatedly, while guiding his unconscious
> body out of the Shrieking Shack. That counts as a fairly
> fresh incident, I should think. And yes, I know Snape had
> just refused to listen to the truth and had gloated over 
> the idea of Sirius being fed to the Dementors. But if Sirius
> had grown out of his animosity toward Snape from their
> adolescent feuds, I'd think he'd just feel pity for Snape
> or ignore him, not then take the opportunity to deliberately
> and rather gleefully injure him, the injury being serious
> or not (presumably the latter). And as previously pointed 
> out, Sirius knows nothing at all of Snape's activities over
> the preceding years since they left school. 
> 
> 
Alla:

Oh I cannot keep quiet lol. Yep Sirius did that, that would be minutes after Snape so nicely suggested that he would give the man who just escaped after thirteen years of Dementors to those dementors  again. I personally would have wanted to do much more damage to Snape than Sirius did in that situation frankly. In any even, Sirius half crazy after Azkaban, Snape does not have the very same excuse as far as I am concerned. But sure, I would agree that they both never grew up of their animosity. The only thing different for me is that Sirius was never given a chance and Snape IMO chose not to.

JMO,

Alla