How would things be different if Snape had gotten the Elder Wand?

kamion53 kersberg at chello.nl
Thu Nov 17 18:33:53 UTC 2011


No: HPFGUIDX 191435



--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Stephanie" <ki4tia at ...> wrote:
>
> Just wondering, if Dumbledore's plan worked. Snaped disarmed him and killed him becoming the owner(?) of the Elder wand. Did Dumbledore tell Snape about the elder wand which he wanted him to have once he was dead?
> 
> Stephanie
>

I think the plot between Dumbledore and Snape was that Snape would not become the next master of the Elder Wand, because he did disarm of beat Dumbledore, but he "euthanesed" Dumbledore at his request.
With Dumbledore dead the mastering of the Elder Wand should stay in limbo because the old master was incapicetated and the new master did not exist.
Draco spoiled their plan as they did not count on the fact that a desperate boy could be quick with his wand. Draco had not beaten Dumbledore by an inch, but that stupid Elder Wand counted a simple disarment as change of masterhood.... even more stupid it counter it when it wasn't even the actual wand from which the master was disarmed.

Harry says in the book canon that he will put the Elder Wand back in the grave, in the movie he simple breaks it in two, which I thought a far stronger move





More information about the HPforGrownups archive