The Overarching message - Caning

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 191650



> > James wrote:
> > Oh, please! Do you REALLY think mind raping Harry over and over was 
> actually a way to TEACH.
> How about I yell at you ready and smash your head with a 2x4. Is this the 
> best way to learn to duck or hit back?
> Have you read the books and actually considered if Harry was your child?
> Caning Harry for a real infraction would be fine with me.
> Taunting and insulting a student and their parents in the class room, to 
> > me, is abuse. <snip>
> 
> Linda:
> When did Snape ever mind rape anyone? This post is offensive in the extreme. Such hate. Wow.

Alla:

I disagree that hating fictional character is offensive to anybody. I also think that Snape mind raped Harry on a regular basis - that is what to me Legilimency is and to me there are plenty of hints in the book that Snape legilimenced Harry when he had no idea that Snape poked around in his mind.