[HPforGrownups] Re: Things that you wish were in the Harry Potter novels -- A ''Good Slytherin''

[Bart Lidofsky]

No: HPFGUIDX 192059

Bruce:
> Mad-Eye Moody was in Slytherin. I would say that he certainly could 
> have been classified as a "good Slytherin." It's true that most of the 
> actions that we thought were Moody's in GoF were actually done by 
> Barty Crouch, Jr (a Ravenclaw), but he had to do what Moody would have 
> done so they do reflect the actions of Alistair Moody. I do like the 
> idea of Upper/Lower sorting. It might very well help get rid of the 
> stereotyping. If you are going to stereotype, however, then you need 
> to remember that nearly as many Death Eaters are Ravenclaws as 
> Slytherins, but their House doesn't share the same reputation.

I specified students for :"good Slytherins". Also, what is the source of 
your statements that Moody was a Slytherin and nearly as many Death 
Eaters are Ravenclaws as Slytherins?

     Bart