Things that you wish were in the Harry Potter novels

[zanooda2]

No: HPFGUIDX 192091









--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, keenefx at ... wrote:

 
>  Since we are on this topic, when in the Deathly Hallows all the 
> Slytherins are confined to their dorms, it seems to remind me 
> (loosely) of the internment of Japanese-Americans after the 
> Pearl Harbor attack.

zanooda:

Brian, the Slytherins were never confined to any dorms. They were just evacuated from the castle before everyone else. True, they were not offered a choice to stay and fight, like the rest of the school, but confined? No, they were *not* confined, on the contrary, they were sent out of the war zone to safety. And if any of them wanted to fight, he/she could always say "no, I'm not leaving, I'm staying and fighting for Hogwarts", right :-)?