> From: "Cindy C." > Subject: Re: Snape's and Black's grudges (was: Living with Sirius) > I don't think this helps Snape, either. First, I am unsure how, when > Snape find the cloak next to the willow, that he knows it belongs to > Harry. In "Snape's Grudge", Harry does not have the cloak in his > pocket when he is taken to Snape's office. I can't think of a prior > instance in the HP series in which Snape sees Harry with the cloak. > But for some reason, when Snape reveals himself in the Shrieking > Shack, he clearly knows the cloak is Harry's. Mini-FLINT? > > Anyway, when Snape finds the cloak, he doesn't necessarily know that > it is Harry's cloak. Harry is not the only wizard with an > invisibility cloak (Moody has one). For all Snape knows, it might be > Lupin's cloak, and Lupin might have used the cloak to sneak out if he > were on his way to transform. One theory jumps to mind: It was, I think, originally James' cloak? I wouldn't be surprised if Snape recognised it immediately from his own runins with WMPP, put two and two together like lightning and jumped up and down with glee. In his mind. Any chance to expell that dispicable Potter boy would have him in fits... --- Liz, laughing though unfortunately having to agree with MMMfanfic's take on driving in NZ... ------------------------------------------------------------- Sign up for ICQmail at http://www.icq.com/icqmail/signup.html