The Ravenclaw Hx identified?

carolynwhite2 carolynwhite2 at carolynwhite2.yahoo.invalid
Wed Aug 3 19:21:30 UTC 2005


--- In the_old_crowd at yahoogroups.com, "davewitley" 
<dfrankiswork at n...> wrote:
> 
> That's not how I see it, rather the reverse.  As long as Harry was 
> focussed on Riddle, he got nowhere - and there's plenty of evidence 
> that Riddle was playing for time in that scene.
> 
> Once he stabs the *diary*, Riddle vanishes and Ginny revives.
> 
> It is true that, had Riddle not come out of the diary, the Basilisk 
> would not have been summoned and harry would not have had a handy 
fang to do the stabbing with.  But I think the inference is that a 
powerful magical entity requires another powerful magical weapon to 
destroy it, not that the fang was effective because Riddle had had a 
hand in its availability.  I take it that, with an appropriate 
weapon, Harry could have destroyed the diary at any time, had he 
known what it really was.
> 
> David

Carolyn:
If that's true, it appears you need to destroy evil with evil. 
Otherwise, JKR could have had him just stick Gryffindor's sword 
through it.

Interesting. Wonder what DD used to destroy the ring.







More information about the the_old_crowd archive