Stupid question about Horscrux!Harry

[nkafkafi]

Neri wrote:
> Big snip
> > I'd imagine Voldy thought Hx!
> > Lily would be Imperio'ed, guarded by his loyal servant, and probably 
> > also controlled by his soul in a similar way that Ginny was 
> > controlled by the Diary Hx. In fact, after we very nearly had Hx!
> > Ginny, a Hx!Lily plan would be the most natural thing.
> > 


> Lyn now:
> But we didn't nearly have a HX Ginny, what we almost had was a dead
Ginny, drained of 
> her life force, to recorporialize a soul fragment which had already
begun that process. 
> <snip>


Neri:
Sorry, I didn't make the point very well. If there was ever a Hx!Lily
plan at all, it obviously never came to be, so I don't see much point
in wondering if we would have got a clone Voldy. I don't think that
was ever Voldy's intention. My point here was different: based on what
we know from the Ginny case, it seems Voldy had reasons to think that
his soul part would be able to control Hx!Lily completely. Therefore,
in Voldy's opinion (although I agree he might have been very wrong in
this) making a Hx!Lily plan wasn't such a risk. 

Neri