More first impressions

[fhmaneely]

--- In the_old_crowd at yahoogroups.com, "nrenka" <nrenka at y...> wrote:
> --- In the_old_crowd at yahoogroups.com, "davewitley" 
> <dfrankiswork at n...> wrote:
> > By our correspondent Phil Space
> > By our correspondent Phil Space
> > By our correspondent Phil Space
> > By our correspondent Phil Space
> > By our correspondent Phil Space
> > By our correspondent Phil Space
> > By our correspondent Phil Space
> > By our correspondent Phil Space
> > By our correspondent Phil Space
> > By our correspondent Phil Space
> > By our correspondent Phil Space
> > By our correspondent Phil Space
> > By our correspondent Phil Space
> > By our correspondent Phil Space
> > By our correspondent Phil Space
> > By our correspondent Phil Space
> > By our correspondent Phil Space
> > By our correspondent Phil Space
> > By our correspondent Phil Space
> > By our correspondent Phil Space
> > By our correspondent Phil Space
> > By our correspondent Phil Space
> > 
> > Hm.  Same first thought for R.A.B as the others. 
> > 
> > Agreed that Snape still has wiggle-room - knowing that Draco was 
> > after him, did Dumbledore discuss possible outcomes with Snape 
and 
> > consider that this offered the best overall chance of doing 
> > Voldemort in?
> 
> Here's the question I have about these events.
> 
> Bellatrix tells us that you have to mean it for Crucio to work.  
Can 
> surrogate anger/emotion be used to do an Unforgivable?  That is to 
> say, do you have to want to make *that* person hurt/dead, or is it 
> enough to have the general emotions of desiring hurt/death?
> 
> If it's the latter, Snape is possibly channeling anger at Voldemort.
> 
> If the former, his fundamental moral character is, ummm, shot.  And 
> that's where I see all the wiggle room for the character but can't 
> quite buy it.
> 
> -Nora has many more thoughts, but notes that most all Moral!Snape 
> ideas seem sunk

Well somebody has to be right about Snape...DD, Bella or Harry.  The 
spinner's end chapt had me thinking too obvious, Snape is still on 
the good side.  Then doing in DD, my thoughts changed on this.  After 
reading everyones posts I am changing again to hmmmmmm not sure.

Had to laugh at Cissy..went to summer camp and bunked with Cissy, 
Muffy and Khaki!
Fran