HBP interview

Amanda Geist editor at mandolabar.yahoo.invalid
Tue Jul 19 17:16:57 UTC 2005


Potioncat:
> There once was a Master of Potions
> .
> Who followed his vengeful notions.
> .
> He'd sneer and he'd snark
> .
> He'd lurk in the dark,
> .
> Thus, inflaming the readers' emotions.

Amandageist:

And also a headmaster wise

Who let all that meanness disguise

The potion-man's task--

Quite handy, to mask

The truth behind their enterprise.

And 

> .
> The Leaky Cauldron/Mugglenet interview is up. Here's one site:
> 
> 
> http://www.mugglenet.com/jkrinterview.shtml
> 
> She answers the question, "Is Snape evil?"  
> 
> Yes she does! She answers the question.

Well. It looks like she does, enough to very much discourage me. But 
remember--we are talking about the woman who has made a second career 
out of not answering questions while she seems to, to the point of 
bemoaning and pointing out when she actually *does.* I think it would 
be very out of character for her to be giving us "Yes"/"No"-value 
answers at this stage--especially if Snape's allegiance is key to 
plot in Book 7.

It still, I think, could go either way.

Earlier interviews--wasn't Snape to redeem himself? "Redeem" is an 
interesting use if it's in spite of his intentions. Hm. Link, anyone 
with more time? 

~Amanda, intrigued






More information about the the_old_crowd archive