HBP: This and that
Trina
triner918 at triner2001.yahoo.invalid
Tue Jul 19 18:24:36 UTC 2005
I'm
really
sorry
we
have
never
learned
more
about
Wendelin
the
Wierd...
What
a
shame,
what
a
shame,
what
a shame!
I managed to read HBP in a 24 hour period with a few interruptions (a
4 hour drive was the biggie)and am now in my 1st re-read.
My immediate thought after finishing it (and mopping up from my
blubs) was "Dammit! When are these people actually going to start
listening to Harry and taking him seriously?" He has repeatedly
proven himself in the last 5 years (as Dumbledore himself admitted in
OoP) and they still tend to blow him off. Yes, he absolutely
despises Draco Malfoy (at first on principle since he was reminded of
his cousin Dudders and then on experience) but everything pointed to
Malfoy, Jr being up to something. And Harry was the one who got
Daddy bunged into Azkaban... Hello, bells should be going off.
I've also never trusted Snape, despite Dumbledore's repeated
insistence that he was trustworthy. However, have you noticed that
while Albus has stated that he would trust Hagrid with his life, he
has *never* said that about Snape? Apropros of what? Something, I'm
sure. I didn't read the scene on the tower as Albus asking for Snape
to kill him, but I am only in the second reading. I know he made the
Unbreakable Vow, which meant he'd die if he broke it. I thought of
PoA when Sirius bellowed at Petticrew, "Then you should have died!
Died rather than betray your friends. As we would have done for you!"
Because he certainly won't be trusted by anyone in the Order now,
regardless if he is still "on the side of angels". He killed Albus
Dumbledore, quite a blow for the Order and quite a help for Voldy and
his minions. I'm also not too fussed with Dumbledore's eyes being
closed. He could have shut them when Snape was saying the
incantation.
I was glad there was more humor this go round. Harry's levitating Ron
out of bed had me in kinks of laughter.
Questions:
Why didn't Harry tell anyone (other than Hermione and Ron) that
Malfoy was going for the Cruciatus curse when he Sectrasempra'd him?
When did Malfoy get the Hand of Glory? In CoS he looked at it and
asked Daddy for it, but it was not purchased at the time. When was
it bought and how do HHR know he has it?
Why is that foul Umbridge woman still at the MoM? And what
unmitagated gall it took for her to show up at the funeral!
I'm sure I'll have other thoughts and questions later...
Trina
More information about the the_old_crowd
archive