[the_old_crowd] Re: My HBP Review

[susiequsie23]

Jim:
That's one of the big problems with Good!Snape. Exactly how does DD's
plan take into account that Harry will do everything he can to kill
Snape on sight?  


SSSusan:
This concerns me, too, Jim.  The *only* thing I can see preventing Harry from icing Snape the second he encounters him is if he somehow comes to understand the role (Good!)Snape presumably played in 6th year & DD's death.  Given Harry's total unwillingness to listen to Snape ["Wait, Harry!  Don't AK me yet! I can explain!"  (Yeah, right.)], the *only* way I can see Harry stopping to listen... and actually potentially believing in Good!Snape... is if DD's portrait in the Headmaster's office has a good long talk with Harry.

Siriusly Snapey Susan


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]