HP Timeline: Neville, Harry, Spoilery
Milz
absinthe at milztoday.yahoo.invalid
Fri Jul 22 18:45:40 UTC 2005
Hi all. I'm a long time member, but first time poster.
After reading HBP, I have some concerns about the Timeline,
specifically the years 1979 to 1981. I'm using the Timeline at the
Lexicon as a reference. I'm looking at the time between
the Prophecy (precise date unknown) and October 24 1981 when Peter
Pettigrew is made the
Potter's Secret Keeper.
http://www.hp-lexicon.org/timelines/main/timeline_1970-1990.html
Per HBP, Dumbledore knows that the child born in July is "the
child". Per the Lexicon Timeline, Dumbledore has this information at
least 1 year before Oct. 24, 1981. Unless wizarding pregnancies are
different than Muggle pregnancies, in early 1980, Dumbledore knows
that Lily Potter and Alice Longbottom are pregnant and the estimated
delivery dates are late July to early August.
Logically, Dumbledore would have put these expectant families under
protective services as soon as he had that prophecy information. As
far as I can tell, the canon isn't specific to the month when the
Prophecy was made, so we don't know the proximity of the Prophecy to
the births of Neville and Harry.
Anyhow, Neville and Harry are born and presumably the Longbottoms and
Potters are in safe houses during the remaining months of 1980 to
Halloween 1981.
According to canon, Peter Pettigrew is made the Potter's secret
keeper on October 24, 1981. IIRC in PoA, Harry learns that
Dumbledore offered to be their secret keeper before they went into
hiding but James wanted Peter to be it. 7 days later, the Potters are
dead and Voldemort is defeated.
So, my question is, what is the date of the prophecy? I can't imagine
that Dumbledore or the Ministry would wait for 1 year before putting
the Potters and Longbottoms in safehouses.
Milz
More information about the the_old_crowd
archive