It was LEWWWpin was Re: PettigrEWWW might still be TREWWW

[pippin_999]

--- In the_old_crowd at yahoogroups.com, "nkafkafi" <nkafkafi at y...>
wrote:
. 
> 
> Of course, Nora really did nothing so impolite as *complaining*, but
> still, I thought it wouldn't do to upset her. I mean, she has good
> connections with Faith <g>. Besides, I kind of liked her
resurrection of TEW EWWWW to be TREWWW myself, until the 
obviousness of S/N hit me on the head like a bludger. So why not 
resurrect TEW EWWWW with just one small change? I've opined more 
than once in the past that if anybody has been secretly in love with 
Lily, my first bet would be Peter. 

Pippin:
Naah, it's Lupin,IMO, whose profession of feelings for Lily caused
that outbreak of goosebumps that Jo got when she went to the movies.
Lily's compassion and reckless trust for  Lupin made her reveal the 
identity of the secret-keeper to him, and Lupin passed the
information to Voldemort  in return for the promise to spare her
life. 

It wouldn't take much rationalizing for Lupin to reach the same
conclusion we did, that the SK switch was useless,  that it was only
a matter of time before that reckless idiot Sirius did something to
give Peter away, such as going to check on him in his hiding place. 
This way, at least Lily would be spared, and Lupin would be honored 
above all others, including that thug Fenrir who was the cause of all
Lupin's misery. Yes.

Speaking of Severus, in all those detention records Harry had to copy
out, weren't there any of Snape's? D'you suppose he really was
careful and clever enough to stay out of trouble, or that he charmed
his records so Harry wouldn't notice them?

Pippin