Tracing ancestry (was: Naughty, Guilty! DD)
cubfanbudwoman
susiequsie23 at cubfanbudwoman.yahoo.invalid
Mon Mar 28 18:36:49 UTC 2005
Anne:
> So you don't like my idea then, that the main Slytherin line passed
> something down through the generations that nobody else knows about?
SSSusan:
Oh, no. I liked that part of your post quite a bit. (Note the
reference, earlier, to all the "juicy bits" in it. :-)) Still
thinking about how I feel about the notion that DD is the
possesser/carrier of it that Slytherin artifact, as you suggest.
Anne:
> P.S. Sure, the McMillans might only count back nine generations
> becasuse in the tenth they hit Muggle, but the principle's still the
> same -- the 900s are a *long* way back.
SSSusan:
Yup, you're right. I just didn't understand Hermione's contention
(if I understood it correctly) that it's be HARDER for wizarding folk
to trace their ancestry than for muggles to do so. That may not have
been what she meant at all, but if it was, I don't get it.
Siriusly Snapey Susan, also congratulating CV for her perseverence.
More information about the the_old_crowd
archive