PSS/SS: Chapter One: The Boy Who Lived
Caius Marcius
coriolan at coriolan_cmc.yahoo.invalid
Sun Apr 9 00:51:22 UTC 2006
--- In the_old_crowd at yahoogroups.com, "Eileen Rebstock"
<erebstock at ...> wrote:
> It struck me listening that it's also our only unfiltered look at
the
> Dursleys. Well, filtered only by the narrator/JKR. Later we see
> everything about them through Harry's eyes. I think they're more
> caricatured that way. Vernon's an idiot in this first chapter, but
you
> do get to see all his worries and fears, and he's much more real
that
> way. I keep wondering how much Petunia's actually let him know
about the
> magical world. It's odd, but he comes across as somewhat bullied by
his
> wife here, afraid to even ask basic questions lest she become angry.
> It's convention to regard Vernon as the bigger bully of the two,
because
> he's loud and stupid, but I think it's Petunia who really calls the
> shots in that family.
>
That's how I've always thought of it, and the strongest confirmation
is in OOP - in chap. 2, Vernon is ready to throw Harry out for good,
but when Dumbledore's Howler arrives, he submissively falls behind
Petunia's decree that Harry must stay. ("If we throw him out, the
neighbours will talk").
- CMC
More information about the the_old_crowd
archive