Take a hint when a hint is intended
Olivier Fouquet
olivier.fouquet at olivierfouquet2000.yahoo.invalid
Tue Mar 21 05:46:36 UTC 2006
Much discussion here and elsewhere focus on trying to guess future
plot development. I have come to look at these attempt with a wary
eye, because past experiences tended to show that JKR does not
provide enough information in previous books to guess about future
plots. However, I have always thought that the series had a strong
thematic component and that on this subject, information were not so
scarce. I particularly enjoy the growing-up part in HP so this is
what I would lie to discuss now. One word of caution. In all that
follows, when I write that something is "about" something, I don't
want to imply that it is only nor even predominantly about it, I just
want to convey the idea that some of the point of the first thing was
to allude to the second. Blame the ambiguity on me mangling English
as if I was Fenrir.
In my opinion, the HP series is about the journey from childhood to
adulthood. Each book yet has been a step.
PS was about abandoning childhood and discovering the wonders and
dangers of adolescence.
CoS was about the danger of a premature sexuality (a bold assertion,
but one I detailed in previous posts, interested reader can read it
many posts, particularly TOL 83372).
PoA was about a teenage boy constructing a positive masculine identity.
GoF could be about the danger of thinking that being adult
automatically implied being responsible. The idea that adult
obsessions are dangerous is there, clearly, but GoF's theme has never
been as clear to me as the others.
OoP was about failure and the difficulty of being a responsible person.
HBP was about accepting love as something positive and normal (here
my word of caution is particularly important: I don't believe this is
the main theme of HBP but it definitely there, I'll spell it in more
details if anyone wishes so).
So what about book 7? Well, a recent rereading of JKR's interviews
plus my own speculations gave me some ideas. What do we know for sure
will be in book 7(either from earlier books or from interviews)?
It will probably start by Bill and Fleur's wedding.
We know that Harry wishes to visit Godric's Hollow and his parent's
grave.
It will be his last stay at the Dursley's, and Ron and Hermione
should be there too (or so they say).
We will probably learn about what Dudley saw when attacked by the
Dementors, about letters between Petunia and DD (both pointed as
significant by JKR in interviews and on her website) and about
Petunia in general
We will learn about the Founders (from an interview).
Dumbledore's family would be a profitable line of inquiry.
We will meet properly a member of the Order that we haven't properly
met yet.
Of course, we know for sure about many other things. What about
reasonable speculation?
It seems reasonable to speculate that we will learn things about
Regulus.
It is likewise reasonable to speculate that Snape's love-life will be
important (Snape has been loved by someone).
Grindelwald has connections to someone (or so it seems).
From all that, I hereby declare that I fully expect book seven to
deal extensively with families, and with the fact that being
responsible for one's family is an important final step to become an
adult. Because idle speculation is worthless but conjectures and
refutations are nice, I go as far as to make a precise conjecture.
I conjecture that Aberforth Dumbledore will play an important role,
that the lady pushing the trolley in the Hogwarts express is related
to Dumbledore too (his sister or step-sister); that part of Snape's
life has entailed failing for his familial obligations (maybe by
failing to protect his family, maybe by turning against it); that
part of his motivations since has been to try to make up for this
(maybe in saving the Dursleys); that the Malfoys were related to
Grindelwald, maybe in league with him, that thus Draco knows or has
the possibility to discover something important (presumably the
location of Cup!Horcrux) and finally that Draco will give Harry this
information for the sake of his family.
I also conjecture that everything above will be disproved in book seven.
Best regards,
Olivier
PS: A liquorice wand to anyone who see the relevance of the title to
the rest of the post, or maybe this is obvious for Americans.
More information about the the_old_crowd
archive