Cheap Tricks and Epiphanies (was: Potion In The Cave

[Catlady (Rita Prince Winston)]

Talisman wrote in
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/the_old_crowd/message/4042  :

<< Hmmm. With a series that explores faked death in nearly every book,
a book (HBP) that openly shows and discusses faked death, and a
character represented by the phoenix, I can't agree that a return from
the seeming-grave would be either a cheap trick or unlikely. I think
it's on the menu, in neon lights. >>

Stupid (at least memory-challenged!) Catlady can't remember faked
death being openly shown in HBP.