Please mark and return wtih comments

[fhmaneely]

--- In the_old_crowd at yahoogroups.com, "susiequsie23" <susiequsie23 at ...> 
wrote:
>
> 
> Fran:
> > On a side note, with all the unanswered questions out there, who was
> > the good Slytherin? Narcissa maybe?
> 
> 
> SSSusan:
> Yeah, I'm thinking Narcissa [even if her motive wasn't 
exactly 'pure'], 
> Sluggy... and Snape, of course. ;-)
> 
> Too bad there was a lack of 'good Slytherins' at the student level, 
> though....
> 
> Siriusly Snapey Susan

I would have been very disheartened if Sluggy would have abandoned 
ship! Fighting in his green silk pj's, probabaly his best pair <g>
The lack of Slytherins in the fight was rather sad. I really thought 
some may join so we see a bit of house unity at last.

Snape, Snape, Snape. Still not happy with him, sorry to say. I do pity 
him. Can you imagine how tormenting it was all those years seeing the 
eyes of his true love embodied in James physical attributes? Still he 
was eager to sacrifice two people to save her. Not so happy with that. 
You can say on the plus side he gave Harry his memory, but I think this 
was more for DD not Harry.

Another side note, Hallows versus Horcrux. Another example of choice 
making us who we are?  The whole camping around the country did not 
bother me so much the second read as I felt an analogy for growing up 
or just growing as a person.

Right turn off the side note: I would really like to know what happened 
to Lucius after all this. Did he loose any pureblood pride at all? Did 
he have a Percy moment?  Guess with all that gold, he and Cissy lead a 
guiet life at Mal-aligned Manor.

Fran
...liked the book,will always love the series, but feel JKR was ready 
to be done with it and could have done a better job.
>