Random thoughts

[mooseming]

--- In the_old_crowd at yahoogroups.com, "Kat Macfarlane" <katmac at ...> 
wrote:
>
> Jo wrote:
> 
> >>>When Harry was killed in the clearing both bits of soul got the 
> signal to move on to the great shunting house in the sky. Like all 
> the other HRX pieces this one didn't return to papa. <<<
> 
> Gatta:
> 
> Was I right in supposing the two soul bits were separated when 
Voldemart "killed" Harry? That is, the Harry that arrived at King's 
Cross was the untainted Harry, and the soul bit from Voldemart was 
the flayed child?
> 
> Purrs!
> 
> Gatta

That's my take on it. The only way to de HRX an item is to destroy 
it with something magical so that's what happened here. 
The container (Harry in this case) is placed beyond magical repair, 
by an AK, and the HRX can no longer exist. 

Blimey! Apart from the 'how come the blood thingy still works in 
this case and not at Privet Drive?', and the 'but he does get fixed 
by magical means' aspects, this piece of plotting might actually 
hold together....

Regards
Jo